| Rank | Num | Name Gym | Vault | Bars | Beam | Floor | AA |
| 1 | 5074 | Ashleigh Lindsey Mid Ohio | 9.150 1 | 9.675 1 | 9.575 1 | 9.525 1 | 37.925 1 |
| 2 | 5196 | Grace Hinson VA Techniques | 8.400 11 | 9.650 2 | 9.450 3 | 9.100 8 | 36.600 2 |
| 3 | 5194 | Erica Boerth VA Techniques | 8.300 15 | 9.050 6 | 9.575 1 | 9.350 2 | 36.275 3 |
| 4 | 5061 | Lauren Muia Flip N Twist | 8.700 4 | 8.950 7 | 9.425 4 | 8.625 11 | 35.700 4 |
| 5 | 5195 | Mackenzie Graham VA Techniques | 8.350 12 | 9.325 3 | 8.800 9 | 9.200 4 | 35.675 5 |
| 6 | 5017 | Mackenzie Wells Winder-Barrow | 8.600 8 | 9.325 3 | 8.275 14 | 9.300 3 | 35.500 6 |
| 7 | 5057 | Larjae Cohen Flip N Twist | 8.600 8 | 8.825 8 | 8.700 10 | 9.150 6 | 35.275 7 |
| 8 | 5047 | Jennifer Doggett Flip Force | 8.850 2 | 8.425 9 | 9.175 6 | 8.750 9 | 35.200 8 |
| 9 | 5048 | Jade Jotcham Flip Force | 8.600 8 | 9.100 5 | 8.150 16 | 9.200 4 | 35.050 9 |
| 10 | 5198 | Madison Padgett VA Techniques | 8.750 3 | 8.375 10 | 8.700 10 | 9.150 6 | 34.975 10 |
| 11 | 5077 | Bethany Miller Mid Ohio | 8.350 12 | 8.175 12 | 9.325 5 | 8.650 10 | 34.500 11 |
| 12 | 5073 | Sara Gier Mid Ohio | 8.300 15 | 8.100 14 | 9.050 7 | 8.400 13 | 33.850 12 |
| 13 | 5064 | Izabella Saliba Flip N Twist | 8.650 5 | 8.200 11 | 8.250 15 | 8.375 14 | 33.475 13 |
| 14 | 5034 | Elizabeth Ashley Wildcard | 8.350 12 | 8.150 13 | 8.425 13 | 8.425 12 | 33.350 14 |
| 15 | 5037 | Alyssa Jones Wildcard | 8.650 5 | 7.200 16 | 9.000 8 | 8.350 15 | 33.200 15 |
| 16 | 5045 | Anna Bolchalk Flip Force | 8.650 5 | 7.750 15 | 7.675 18 | 8.125 17 | 32.200 16 |
| 17 | 5038 | Madelyn Jordan Wildcard | 8.000 17 | 6.250 18 | 8.475 12 | 8.000 18 | 30.725 17 |
| 18 | 5067 | Anna Taylor Flip N Twist | 7.100 18 | 6.500 17 | 7.925 17 | 8.150 16 | 29.675 18 |